102 - A Star Is Born

Hyped up, already very successful, and widely well-received, A Star Is Born earns strong reactions from us. To Mike it's at points truly reprehensible, to José simply a confused failure. Mike has never seen any of the previous versions - he tried and couldn't make it - while José finds writer/director/star Bradley Cooper's new remake unworthy to share their company. The novelty of seeing Lady Gaga unmasked soon wears off, her performance opaque and lacking in presence. We agree that Cooper is very good and truly a star, though with the opprobrium he receives from one half of us, he must have done something to Mike in a previous life. We discuss and debate what we make of the film's characters - Mike finds them deeply unlikeable, toxically compatible, which isn't in itself a bad thing but for the fact that the film wants to render it romantic. (Cooper has a real problem with consent and personal space.) José finds their love difficult to believe in, particularly Gaga's for Cooper. Quite why she's so hot for him is barely even told, let alone shown. Cooper's take on the music industry is out of date and simplistic, which is more than disappointing considering he was working with one of the biggest pop stars of the last decade. We each have our reasons for finding the suicide scene nonsensical. And Mike describes his problem with the film's ending. A lot to talk about, most of it negative. See you again in between twenty and forty years for the next version. Recorded on 8th October 2018.